Matchup · 2026
Carlisle at Pleasantville
Projected line
Pleasantville at home
Carlisle -15.5o/u 47.5
Carlisle 31 · Pleasantville 16
84%
Carlisle at home
Carlisle -17.5o/u 47.5
Pleasantville 15 · Carlisle 32
87%
Neutral site
Carlisle -16.5o/u 47.5
Carlisle 32 · Pleasantville 15
86%
| Site | Line | Total | Win prob | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pleasantville at home | Carlisle -15.5 | 47.5 | 84% | Carlisle 31 · Pleasantville 16 |
| Carlisle at home | Carlisle -17.5 | 47.5 | 87% | Pleasantville 15 · Carlisle 32 |
| Neutral site | Carlisle -16.5 | 47.5 | 86% | Carlisle 32 · Pleasantville 15 |
Series history
39–28
Carlisle leads
67
Meetings · 1928–2011
10–0
Last 10 · Carlisle
10
Carlisle streak
Biggest wins
Carlisle
50-0 · 1967+50
47-6 · 2011+41
46-6 · 1992+40
Pleasantville
46-0 · 1994+46
47-6 · 1996+41
48-7 · 1995+41
Runs & venue
Longest streak: Carlisle 10 straight, 2002–2011
Home team: 36-31
Playoff meetings: 0
Average margin: 18.4 · decided by 7 or less: 18
By decade · avg margin, Pleasantville view
| 2010s | 0-2 | -34.0 |
| 2000s | 1-9 | -18.2 |
| 1990s | 7-3 | +8.5 |
| 1980s | 6-4 | +8.1 |
| 1970s | 2-8 | -11.7 |
| 1960s | 3-7 | -5.8 |
| 1950s | 5-4 | -4.2 |
| 1940s | 2-0 | +23.0 |
| 1930s | 0-1 | -1.0 |
| 1920s | 2-1 | +4.0 |
| Season | Result | Model line |
|---|---|---|
| 2011 Aug 26 | Carlisle 47-6 at Pleasantville | — — |
| 2010 Aug 27 | Carlisle 47-20 at Carlisle | Carlisle -36.5 no cover |
| 2009 Aug 28 | Carlisle 52-20 at Pleasantville | — — |
| 2008 Aug 29 | Carlisle 35-14 at Carlisle | — — |
| 2007 Sep 7 | Carlisle 28-6 at Carlisle | — — |
| 2006 Sep 8 | Carlisle 32-6 at Pleasantville | — — |
| 2005 Sep 9 | Carlisle 21-14 at Carlisle | — — |
| 2004 Sep 10 | Carlisle 26-0 at Pleasantville | — — |
| 2003 Sep 12 | Carlisle 37-6 at Carlisle | — — |
| 2002 Sep 13 | Carlisle 28-8 at Pleasantville | — — |
| 2001 Sep 7 | Pleasantville 14-0 at Carlisle | — — |
| 2000 Sep 8 | Carlisle 38-27 at Pleasantville | — — |
| 1999 Sep 10 | Pleasantville 34-31 at Carlisle | Carlisle -17.5 no cover |
| 1998 Sep 11 | Carlisle 40-14 at Pleasantville | — — |
| 1997 Sep 12 | Pleasantville 31-21 at Carlisle | — — |
| 1996 Sep 13 | Pleasantville 47-6 at Pleasantville | — — |
| 1995 Sep 8 | Pleasantville 48-7 at Carlisle | — — |
| 1994 Sep 9 | Pleasantville 46-0 at Pleasantville | Carlisle -7.5 no cover |
| 1993 Sep 10 | Carlisle 14-12 at Carlisle | — — |
| 1992 Sep 11 | Carlisle 46-6 at Pleasantville | — — |
| 1991 Sep 13 | Pleasantville 14-12 at Carlisle | Pleasantville -2.0 push |
| 1990 Sep 7 | Pleasantville 16-6 at Pleasantville | — — |
| 1989 Sep 1 | Carlisle 26-21 at Carlisle | — — |
| 1988 Sep 2 | Carlisle 12-0 at Pleasantville | Carlisle -3.5 covered |
| 1987 Sep 4 | Carlisle 12-6 at Carlisle | Carlisle -1.5 covered |
| 1986 Sep 5 | Pleasantville 14-0 at Pleasantville | — — |
| 1985 Sep 6 | Carlisle 34-8 at Carlisle | — — |
| 1984 Sep 7 | Pleasantville 21-6 at Pleasantville | Pleasantville -15.5 no cover |
| 1983 Sep 2 | Pleasantville 34-0 at Carlisle | — — |
| 1982 Sep 3 | Pleasantville 34-13 at Pleasantville | — — |
| 1981 Sep 4 | Pleasantville 28-14 at Carlisle | — — |
| 1980 Sep 5 | Pleasantville 40-8 at Pleasantville | — — |
| 1979 Sep 7 | Carlisle 6-0 at Carlisle | — — |
| 1978 Sep 8 | Carlisle 27-6 at Carlisle | — — |
| 1977 Sep 9 | Carlisle 14-6 at Carlisle | — — |
| 1975 Sep 5 | Carlisle 28-6 at Carlisle | Carlisle -17.5 covered |
| 1974 Sep 6 | Carlisle 15-2 at Pleasantville | Pleasantville -12.5 no cover |
| 1974 Sep 6 | Carlisle 15-2 at Carlisle | Pleasantville -10.5 no cover |
| 1973 Sep 7 | Pleasantville 20-6 at Carlisle | — — |
| 1972 Sep 8 | Pleasantville 26-6 at Pleasantville | — — |
| 1971 Sep 10 | Carlisle 42-6 at Carlisle | — — |
| 1970 Sep 11 | Carlisle 44-12 at Pleasantville | — — |
| 1969 Sep 12 | Carlisle 20-6 at Carlisle | — — |
| 1968 Sep 13 | Carlisle 12-6 at Carlisle | — — |
| 1967 Sep 15 | Carlisle 50-0 at Carlisle | — — |
| 1966 Sep 9 | Carlisle 31-0 at Pleasantville | — — |
| 1965 Sep 10 | Pleasantville 39-6 at Carlisle | — — |
| 1964 Sep 11 | Carlisle 23-12 at Pleasantville | — — |
| 1963 Sep 13 | Carlisle 14-12 at Carlisle | — — |
| 1962 Sep 14 | Carlisle 13-0 at Pleasantville | — — |
| 1961 Sep 15 | Pleasantville 19-0 at Carlisle | — — |
| 1960 Sep 23 | Pleasantville 24-7 at Pleasantville | — — |
| 1959 Sep 25 | Pleasantville 19-6 at Carlisle | — — |
| 1958 Sep 26 | Carlisle 13-7 at Pleasantville | — — |
| 1957 Sep 27 | Pleasantville 6-0 at Carlisle | — — |
| 1956 Sep 28 | Pleasantville 12-7 at Pleasantville | — — |
| 1955 Sep 23 | Carlisle 31-0 at Carlisle | — — |
| 1954 Sep 24 | Pleasantville 6-0 at Pleasantville | — — |
| 1951 Oct 26 | Pleasantville 7-6 at Pleasantville | — — |
| 1951 Oct 12 | Carlisle 7-0 at Carlisle | — — |
| 1950 Oct 27 | Carlisle 31-6 at Pleasantville | — — |
| 1949 Oct 28 | Pleasantville 40-6 at Carlisle | — — |
| 1948 Oct 22 | Pleasantville 25-13 at Carlisle | — — |
| 1933 Nov 2 | Carlisle 7-6 at Carlisle | — — |
| 1929 Nov 15 | Pleasantville 7-0 at Carlisle | — — |
| 1929 Oct 25 | Pleasantville 12-0 at Pleasantville | — — |
| 1928 Oct 26 | Carlisle 7-0 at Carlisle | — — |
Every recorded meeting in Brent Moore's all-time archive. Model lines appear for seasons whose archive pages have been built (2021 on, plus any older season you have opened).