Series history · 1927–1959
Carlisle vs Melcher
No projected line: at least one of these programs is not an eleven-player team in the 2026 season file.
Series history
6–4
Carlisle leads
10
Meetings · 1927–1959
6–4
Last 10 · Carlisle
2
Carlisle streak
Biggest wins
Carlisle
36-6 · 1959+30
30-7 · 1950+23
20-0 · 1958+20
Melcher
31-0 · 1927+31
19-0 · 1930+19
6-0 · 1957+6
Runs & venue
Longest streak: Carlisle 4 straight, 1933–1951
Home team: 4-6
Playoff meetings: 0
Average margin: 15.5 · decided by 7 or less: 4
By decade · avg margin, Melcher view
| 1950s | 2-4 | -11.5 |
| 1940s | 0-1 | -13.0 |
| 1930s | 1-1 | +9.0 |
| 1920s | 1-0 | +31.0 |
| Season | Result | Model line |
|---|---|---|
| 1959 Sep 11 | Carlisle 36-6 at Melcher | — — |
| 1958 Sep 12 | Carlisle 20-0 at Melcher | — — |
| 1957 Sep 13 | Melcher 6-0 at Melcher | — — |
| 1956 Sep 14 | Melcher 12-7 at Carlisle | — — |
| 1951 Sep 21 | Carlisle 7-0 at Melcher | — — |
| 1950 Sep 22 | Carlisle 30-7 at Carlisle | — — |
| 1949 Sep 23 | Carlisle 13-0 at Melcher | — — |
| 1933 Sep 30 | Carlisle 7-6 at Carlisle | — — |
| 1930 Nov 27 | Melcher 19-0 at Carlisle | — — |
| 1927 Oct 8 | Melcher 31-0 at Melcher | — — |
Every recorded meeting in Brent Moore's all-time archive. Model lines appear for seasons whose archive pages have been built (2021 on, plus any older season you have opened).