Series history · 1904–1957
Menlo vs Casey
No projected line: at least one of these programs is not an eleven-player team in the 2026 season file.
Series history
19–7–1
Casey leads
27
Meetings · 1904–1957
9–1
Last 10 · Casey
1
Menlo streak
Biggest wins
Menlo
43-6 · 1927+37
33-0 · 1957+33
26-6 · 1931+20
Casey
62-0 · 1953+62
47-0 · 1952+47
45-6 · 1955+39
Runs & venue
Longest streak: Casey 9 straight, 1950–1956
Home team: 14-12-1
Playoff meetings: 0
Average margin: 20.3 · decided by 7 or less: 6
By decade · avg margin, Casey view
| 1950s | 9-1 | +22.3 |
| 1940s | 5-2-1 | +8.1 |
| 1930s | 3-3 | -2.3 |
| 1920s | 0-1 | -37.0 |
| 1900s | 2-0 | +21.0 |
| Season | Result | Model line |
|---|---|---|
| 1957 Oct 4 | Menlo 33-0 at Casey | — — |
| 1956 Oct 5 | Casey 36-13 at Menlo | — — |
| 1955 Sep 30 | Casey 45-6 at Casey | — — |
| 1954 Oct 1 | Casey 26-0 at Menlo | — — |
| 1953 Oct 2 | Casey 62-0 at Casey | — — |
| 1952 Oct 16 | Casey 47-0 at Menlo | — — |
| 1952 Oct 3 | Casey 32-7 at Casey | — — |
| 1951 Oct 19 | Casey 13-6 at Casey | — — |
| 1951 Oct 5 | Casey 20-0 at Menlo | — — |
| 1950 Oct 20 | Casey 13-6 at Menlo | — — |
| 1949 Nov 11 | Menlo 13-0 at Menlo | — — |
| 1949 Sep 30 | Casey 15-0 at Casey | — — |
| 1946 Nov 6 | Tie 13-13 at Casey | — — |
| 1946 Oct 4 | Casey 25-0 at Menlo | — — |
| 1944 Oct 6 | Casey 19-6 at Menlo | — — |
| 1943 Nov 11 | Casey 32-0 at Casey | — — |
| 1943 Oct 8 | Casey 18-7 at Menlo | — — |
| 1941 Nov 6 | Menlo 18-0 at Casey | — — |
| 1939 Nov 10 | Casey 6-0 at Casey | — — |
| 1938 Nov 11 | Casey 13-0 at Casey | — — |
| 1937 Nov 11 | Menlo 2-0 at Casey | — — |
| 1934 Nov 9 | Menlo 20-8 at Casey | — — |
| 1933 Nov 10 | Casey 3-2 at Casey | — — |
| 1931 Nov 6 | Menlo 26-6 at Menlo | — — |
| 1927 Oct 12 | Menlo 43-6 at Menlo | — — |
| 1904 Oct 29 | Casey 25-0 at Casey | — — |
| 1904 Oct 1 | Casey 17-0 at Casey | — — |
Every recorded meeting in Brent Moore's all-time archive. Model lines appear for seasons whose archive pages have been built (2021 on, plus any older season you have opened).