Series history · 1931–1957
Casey vs Earlham
No projected line: at least one of these programs is not an eleven-player team in the 2026 season file.
Series history
11–1
Earlham leads
12
Meetings · 1931–1957
9–1
Last 10 · Earlham
3
Earlham streak
Biggest wins
Casey
6-0 · 1953+6
Earlham
68-0 · 1950+68
59-0 · 1931+59
43-0 · 1957+43
Runs & venue
Longest streak: Earlham 8 straight, 1931–1952
Home team: 8-4
Playoff meetings: 0
Average margin: 25.9 · decided by 7 or less: 4
By decade · avg margin, Earlham view
| 1950s | 6-1 | +27.6 |
| 1940s | 4-0 | +11.8 |
| 1930s | 1-0 | +59.0 |
| Season | Result | Model line |
|---|---|---|
| 1957 Sep 13 | Earlham 43-0 at Casey | — — |
| 1956 Sep 14 | Earlham 27-6 at Earlham | — — |
| 1955 Sep 9 | Earlham 6-0 at Casey | — — |
| 1953 Sep 11 | Casey 6-0 at Casey | — — |
| 1952 Sep 12 | Earlham 42-0 at Earlham | — — |
| 1951 Sep 14 | Earlham 26-7 at Casey | — — |
| 1950 Sep 15 | Earlham 68-0 at Earlham | — — |
| 1949 Sep 16 | Earlham 7-0 at Casey | — — |
| 1948 Sep 17 | Earlham 27-6 at Earlham | — — |
| 1946 Sep 20 | Earlham 12-6 at Earlham | — — |
| 1944 Sep 15 | Earlham 13-0 at Earlham | — — |
| 1931 Sep 18 | Earlham 59-0 at Earlham | — — |
Every recorded meeting in Brent Moore's all-time archive. Model lines appear for seasons whose archive pages have been built (2021 on, plus any older season you have opened).